Tell government to abandon nuclear and invest in 100% Black-owned renewable energy

sign sign
Tell government to abandon nuclear and invest in 100% Black-owned renewable energy
Tell government to abandon nuclear and invest in 100% Black-owned renewable energy
2,000 signatures required

Today, many communities across the country remain either locked out of basic infrastructure in informal settlements and rural areas, or trapped in quickly increasing electricity costs which make everyday a bitter struggle for survival. What makes this worse is that private sector greed, government mismanagement, poor planning and corruption have led to periodic load shedding which hits Black working class areas the hardest. So, the question is, what is our government planning to do to increase access and reduce the cost of electricity?

We’ve heard government talk a lot about their commitment to nuclear as being part of our energy future, and while the Finance Minister says we cannot afford nuclear right now, and the Energy Minister says there is no nuclear deal on the table, the Department of Environmental Affairs has just granted Eskom permission to build a nuclear power plant at Duynefontein, north of the Cape Flats. What is more, Energy Minister Mahlobo gave only a couple weeks’ notice for a public consultation on nuclear energy in the form of an Energy Indaba. Of further concern is the lack of publicly available information on the Indaba and that it seems to be invite only public consultation event! Minister Mahlobo’s actions are worrying, especially because the latest draft Integrated Resource Plan for Electricity (IRP) for 2017 suggests that nuclear would be the most expensive source of electricity, compared to solar, wind and coal [1]. Whether the nuclear industry and Energy Minister like it or not, the courts are on our side and we will make sure our voices are heard.

How can we build more nuclear facilities if we cannot protect or compensate workers exposed to radiation?

To date, numerous South Africans have been exposed to nuclear material, including at Pelindaba. Many have died, and those who survive have severe health issues and are still waiting for compensation [8] [9] [10] [11].

Isn’t solar a better idea?

Rosatom, a Russian state owned nuclear company, changed their estimate for jobs that could be created through building a new nuclear plant from 15,000 to 5,760. While jobs in renewable energy such as solar and wind are said to be creating 13 times more jobs than nuclear [12]. The Institute for Sustainable Futures’ research suggests a phased switch to renewable energy generation in South Africa, which includes the domestic manufacture of renewable technologies, could create approximately 180,000 new jobs by 2030 [12].


There are already eight 100% Black owned renewable energy companies ready and waiting for Eskom to sign their Independent Power Producer agreements [13]. However, the Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer (REIPP), while less problematic than nuclear, is not a long term solution as it is part of a privatisation agenda. Instead, we join those in the labour movement [14] who have called for democratised, community and worker owned renewable energy, where the profits and benefits of renewable energy flow to the people and not elites. As Mzansi phases out coal, it is critical that a just transition is achieved. Community owned renewable energy can ensure coal workers have jobs in green energy.

Dear Energy Minister Jeff Radebe, Eskom Interim Group Chief Executive Sean Maritz, Nersa CEO Chris Forlee, President Cyril Ramaphosa and Deputy President David Mabuza,

We the undersigned call on the Cabinet, Department of Energy and Eskom to hear our voices and adopt a new resolution to abandon nuclear procurement forever. The proposed Energy Indaba on the 7th and 8th December is offensive to the very idea of public consultation. Therefore, we the people will drive this public consultation and make you aware of the following:

- Nuclear is unnecessary, dangerous, expensive, does not create cheaper electricity, may not create as many jobs as renewables, and will not transform our economy.
- We call on you to sign the agreements of 100% Black owned REIPP proposals immediately; however, we call on you to put in place a 5% cap on IPP contributions to our grid, phase out the IPP programme, and replace it with cooperative, community owned democratised renewable energy, in line with NUMSA’s call for “renewable energy parastatals and municipal-owned renewable energy entities that are under democratic control through constituency-based governing councils and with a strong social mandate to provide energy services, fight energy poverty/inequality and extend the right to energy”.
- We call on you to ensure that there are no job losses in the coal sector by pursuing IPPs, and instead phase in para-statal, cooperative or municipal owned renewable energy that ensure green energy jobs. This requires flexibility in ownership models, and a departure from the privatisation mentality of IPPs.
- We call on government to apply pressure on NECSA to urgently compensate all workers for exposure to radiation, chemicals and unsafe working conditions, and to provide them with urgent medical treatment and tests in a transparent manner.

We expect our demands to be considered as part of the Energy Indaba’s so called ‘public consultation’ as well as future public consultation driven by government, Eskom and NERSA.


[1] Eskom’s latest work on energy policy plan rejects nuclear. Chris Yelland News 25 November 24 2017

[2] Health Risks from Exposure to Low Levels of Ionizing Radiation: BEIR VII Phase 2 (2006) National Research Council (US) Committee to Assess Health Risks from Exposure to Low Level of Ionizing Radiation. Washington, D.C. : National Academies Press, c2006.

[3] World Health Organisation "World Health Organization report explains the health impacts of the world's worst-ever civil nuclear accident", WHO, 26 April 2006

[4] SEISMIC STRESS TEST OF KOEBERG NPP". CKTI-Vibroseism Ltd. CKTI-Vibroseism Ltd. Retrieved 7 January 2015.

[5] Physicians for Social Responsibility Cites Flawed Evacuation Zones, Nuclear’s Health Risks on Chernobyl Anniversary. April 26, 2011

[6] Eskom welcomes the Department of Environmental Affairs’ authorisation for the Duynefontein site. Eskom Press Release Friday, 13 October 2017.

[7] Jubilation as nuclear vetoed for Thyspunt, Guy Rogers for Herald Live October 17, 2017

[8] Apartheid’s Nuclear Shame. Mandy de Waal and Jon Pienaar for Ground Up 27 June 2014

[9] Desperately seeking justice. Sheree Bega Independent Online 10 December 2016

[10] Nuclear Energy Impact in South Africa: public hearings

[11] 'I thought it would help me get a promotion' Shaun Smillie for Independent Online 6 May 2005

[12] 9 Things You Need To Know About The Nuclear Deal And Energy Justice. Pooven Moodley Natasha Adonis Huffington Post 22 November 2017.

[13] What experts say about Eskom’s excuses for renewable delays. Charlotte Matthews Business Live 29 June 2017

[14] NUMSA Speech: Motivations For a Socially-Owned Renewable Energy Sector. October 2012

Will you sign?

Tell the Minister of Energy to forget nuclear power, and instead sign the current 100% Black owned renewable energy agreements and phase in community owned renewable energy cooperatives which are safer, faster, cheaper and could create more jobs.